7 Terrifying Startup Risks and How Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI) Saves Your Business
So, you’ve just closed your seed round.
The coffee machine is humming, the code is compiling, and your team is buzzing with that beautiful, chaotic energy that only a startup can generate.
It feels like you’re on top of the world, right?
You’re a visionary, a disruptor, a founder who’s going to change the game.
You’ve got a product roadmap that’s a work of art and a sales forecast that’s a dream come true.
But let me ask you a question that might make you shift uncomfortably in your ergonomic chair: what happens when one of your employees sues you?
Just imagine for a second.
One of your rockstar developers files a wrongful termination suit.
Or maybe two team members get into a heated argument, and one accuses the other—and your company—of harassment.
Or an interview with a promising candidate goes sideways, and you’re suddenly facing a discrimination claim.
That’s the kind of nightmare that can bring a high-flying startup crashing back to earth faster than a botched product launch.
You see, as a founder, your to-do list is a mile long.
You’re worried about product-market fit, fundraising, hiring, and probably what’s for dinner.
But buried deep beneath all that innovation and hustle is a ticking time bomb most founders don’t even know exists: **Employment Practices Liability**.
And that, my friend, is why you need to understand and get **Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI)**.
It’s not just another line item on a budget spreadsheet.
It’s a crucial shield that protects the company you’ve poured your heart and soul into.
I’ve seen it time and time again in my years in the insurance world—a small, seemingly innocent HR hiccup can balloon into a legal and financial catastrophe.
I’ve sat with founders who thought they had everything covered, only to watch their dreams unravel in a courtroom.
Their biggest regret? Not getting EPLI sooner.
So, let’s talk about what EPLI is, why it’s a non-negotiable for any startup, and how you can get it right.
Consider this your founder’s guide to sleeping better at night. —
Table of Contents
—
What Exactly Is Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI)? Your Startup’s Ultimate Shield
Think of **Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI)** as a legal force field for your startup’s human resources department.
It’s an insurance policy that protects your business from claims made by employees, or even former employees, alleging that their legal rights as employees were violated.
Let me put it in plain English, without all the boring insurance jargon.
You know how car insurance covers you when you get into a fender bender?
EPLI is like that, but for employment issues.
It’s designed to cover your legal defense costs and settlement fees if an employee sues you.
And trust me, those costs can be absolutely astronomical.
A single lawsuit can wipe out your entire operating budget, forcing you to choose between paying a lawyer and keeping the lights on.
It’s the kind of decision no founder should ever have to make.
What kind of claims does EPLI typically cover?
It’s a broad range, but the most common ones include:
Wrongful Termination: Firing an employee seems straightforward, right? But if they can argue it was for an illegal reason (like retaliation for whistleblowing or discrimination), you’re in for a fight.
Workplace Harassment: This could be sexual harassment, or harassment based on race, religion, gender, or any other protected class. Even if the claim is baseless, defending it will cost you a fortune.
Discrimination: This covers claims related to hiring, firing, promotions, or compensation based on protected characteristics like age, gender, race, or disability.
Failure to Promote: An employee could allege they were passed over for a promotion due to discriminatory reasons.
Retaliation: An employee reports something, and then they’re disciplined or fired. They might claim your actions were in retaliation for their report.
Breach of Employment Contract: If you have an employment agreement, you better make sure you stick to it. EPLI can cover claims if you don’t.
Wage and Hour Violations: This is a big one. Think misclassifying employees, failing to pay overtime, or not providing proper meal and rest breaks. The regulations are complex, and it’s easy to make a mistake.
Now, here’s a little secret: many founders think they’re too small to be a target.
They assume that big corporations with thousands of employees are the ones who get sued.
But in reality, startups are often more vulnerable.
You don’t have a seasoned HR department with lawyers on retainer.
You’re probably wearing multiple hats, and HR is just one of them—and probably not your favorite one.
This lack of dedicated expertise means a simple mistake, a misinterpreted conversation, or a poorly written termination letter can expose you to massive liability.
This is where EPLI steps in.
It provides you with a safety net, so you can focus on building your company instead of worrying about a legal landmine every time you have a difficult conversation with an employee. —
The 7 Terrifying Threats Your Startup Faces Without Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI)
You might be thinking, “Hey, my team is a family. We all get along. We’re building something great together. We don’t have these problems.”
And that’s a beautiful thought.
It really is.
But the reality of business is often far messier than the startup dream.
Let’s walk through some of the most common scenarios that can go from zero to lawsuit in the blink of an eye.
These aren’t hypothetical nightmares; they’re real-world risks that startups face every single day.
I’ve seen all of these, and trust me, they’re not pretty.
### 1. The “Bad Fit” Employee Who Becomes a Legal Nightmare
You hire someone who seems perfect on paper, but a few months in, it’s clear they’re not the right cultural fit.
Their performance is slipping, and they’re creating a toxic atmosphere.
So you decide to let them go.
Seems reasonable, right?
But what if that employee, on their way out, claims they were fired because of their age, gender, or a medical condition they mentioned in passing?
They can easily file a lawsuit for **wrongful termination**.
Without EPLI, you’re on the hook for all the legal fees, even if the case is completely unfounded.
And the average cost to defend a wrongful termination suit?
We’re talking tens of thousands of dollars, easily.
### 2. The Off-Hand Joke That Becomes a Harassment Claim
Startup culture is often casual and relaxed.
Team members share jokes, memes, and maybe even a few off-color comments.
But what one person sees as a harmless joke, another might see as harassment.
Let’s say a manager makes a joke about someone’s religious holiday that they think is lighthearted.
The employee is deeply offended and files a **harassment** claim.
The company is suddenly liable for creating a hostile work environment.
Your “fun” office culture can turn into a legal liability faster than you can say “hostile work environment.”
### 3. The Unintended Bias in the Hiring Process
You’re hiring a new senior engineer.
You’ve got a stack of resumes, and you’re looking for someone who fits the vibe of your young, energetic team.
You unconsciously favor candidates who remind you of your current employees—all of whom are in their late 20s or early 30s.
You pass on a highly qualified candidate who happens to be over 50.
That candidate could easily argue they were a victim of **age discrimination**.
Discrimination claims don’t just happen during terminations; they can arise at any stage of the employment lifecycle, including hiring.
### 4. The Retaliation Trap
A team member comes to you with a complaint about another employee.
Maybe it’s about a minor breach of company policy or a disagreement over a project.
You handle the situation, but a few weeks later, you decide to fire the employee who made the complaint for unrelated performance issues.
They might turn around and sue you for **retaliation**, claiming they were fired for making the complaint, even if their performance was genuinely poor.
Proving your intent was not retaliatory is a huge challenge without the right legal resources, which EPLI provides.
### 5. Wage and Hour Claims from a Single Misclassification
This one is a real killer.
You hire a freelance developer to help with a big project.
They work exclusively for you, use your equipment, and report to your project manager.
The government might argue they should have been classified as an employee, not a contractor.
Suddenly, you’re on the hook for back pay, overtime, and penalties.
**Wage and hour violations** can be incredibly complex and are one of the most common types of lawsuits startups face.
### 6. The “Unfair” Performance Review
You give an employee a poor performance review, outlining areas for improvement.
They get angry, claiming the review is unfair and that your feedback is based on a protected characteristic—like a disability they mentioned in an email.
They file a **defamation** claim against you, arguing the poor review damaged their professional reputation.
This is an example of how even a standard HR process can become a legal risk.
### 7. The Public-Facing Founder’s Social Media Faux Pas
Founders are often the face of their brand.
Their social media presence is part of their professional identity.
But what if a founder makes a comment on Twitter or LinkedIn that an employee finds offensive or discriminatory?
This can open the door to a lawsuit, even if the comment wasn’t directly aimed at the employee.
The line between personal and professional can be very blurry for founders, and EPLI helps protect the company from the fallout of such incidents.
The scary thing about all of these scenarios is that they don’t require malicious intent.
They can happen to a well-meaning founder who just makes a simple, innocent mistake.
That’s why EPLI isn’t a luxury; it’s a necessity.
It’s the shield that protects you from the very real, very expensive consequences of running a business with human beings.
And if you want to see just how common these issues are, take a look at the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) data.
Every year, they receive tens of thousands of charges of discrimination.
It’s a statistic that should make every founder sit up and pay attention.
This isn’t an imaginary boogeyman; it’s a real and present danger to your startup’s survival. —
EPLI vs. Directors & Officers (D&O) Insurance: What’s the Difference and Why You Need Both
This is one of the most common points of confusion for startup founders.
Many think that if they have Directors & Officers (D&O) insurance, they’re automatically covered for employment-related lawsuits.
I’m here to tell you, as a friend and a professional, that this is a dangerous misconception.
Let me break it down with a simple analogy.
Think of your startup as a fancy sports car.
**D&O insurance** is like the seatbelt and airbag system.
It protects the people inside the car—the drivers and passengers, who in this case are your directors and officers.
D&O insurance covers them for legal claims related to their decisions and actions in their official capacity as leaders of the company.
For example, if your investors sue your board members for mismanagement of company funds, D&O insurance would kick in.
It protects them from lawsuits by shareholders, creditors, or even the government.
It’s about corporate governance and financial oversight.
Now, **EPLI** is like the car’s anti-lock braking system and traction control.
It’s designed to protect the car itself—your business—from a very specific type of accident: employment-related claims.
EPLI covers the company and its employees (including directors and officers) against claims from *employees*.
See the difference?
D&O is for claims against the leadership *from external parties or shareholders*.
EPLI is for claims against the company *from employees*.
The two policies are not interchangeable, and they address fundamentally different types of risks.
It’s possible to get a combined D&O and EPLI policy, which can be a cost-effective solution for a startup.
But the key takeaway is this: don’t assume one covers the other.
If an employee sues you for wrongful termination, and you only have D&O insurance, you could be in for a rude awakening when your D&O policy denies the claim.
It happens more often than you’d think.
And in that moment, all the money you saved by not getting EPLI will seem like a pittance compared to the legal bills piling up on your desk.
For a more detailed breakdown of the differences, you can check out this resource from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), which provides guidance on a range of insurance topics for public companies.
—
When Should a Startup Get EPLI? (Spoiler: The Moment You Make Your First Hire)
Here’s a question I get all the time: “I only have five employees. Do I really need EPLI yet?”
The short, direct, and non-negotiable answer is yes.
The moment you hire your first employee, you open yourself up to employment practices liability.
It doesn’t matter if it’s one person or one thousand.
The risk is there from day one.
Think of it this way: when you buy a car, you don’t wait until you’ve had your first accident to get insurance, do you?
Of course not.
You get it before you even drive it off the lot.
EPLI is the same.
It’s a proactive measure, not a reactive one.
Many startups make the mistake of waiting until they hit a certain number of employees—10, 25, 50, or even 100—before they consider EPLI.
But the data tells a different story.
In fact, many employment lawsuits are filed by a single disgruntled employee, regardless of the company’s size.
And for a small startup, a single lawsuit is a far greater threat than it is for a multi-billion dollar corporation.
For a company with 100 employees, a $50,000 legal bill is a nuisance.
For a company with 5 employees, it could be a death sentence.
So, the best time to get EPLI is now.
The moment you have payroll and are responsible for someone else’s livelihood, you need this protection.
It’s a foundational piece of your business’s legal and financial infrastructure, just like your articles of incorporation and your business bank account.
Some investors, in fact, are starting to require their portfolio companies to have adequate insurance coverage, including EPLI, as a condition of their investment.
They understand that an uninsured employment lawsuit could tank their investment.
It’s a sign of a mature, well-run company to have these protections in place from the start. —
How Much Does EPLI Cost for a Startup? The Price of Peace of Mind
So, you’re convinced.
You know you need EPLI.
But a question is probably burning in your mind: “How much is this going to cost me?”
The cost of EPLI, like most insurance policies, isn’t a one-size-fits-all number.
It’s a dynamic price that depends on a variety of factors.
But I can give you a general idea.
For a small startup with 1-10 employees, you could be looking at a premium of a few thousand dollars a year.
It’s not free, but it’s a tiny fraction of what a single lawsuit could cost you.
For a company with 50-100 employees, the cost will naturally be higher, as the risk exposure is greater.
What factors influence the cost?
Number of Employees: This is the most significant factor. The more employees you have, the higher the risk of a claim, and the higher the premium.
Industry: Some industries are considered higher-risk than others. For example, a company in a highly regulated industry or one with a high turnover rate might pay more.
State of Operation: Employment laws vary by state, and some states, like California, are notoriously employee-friendly, which increases the risk for employers and drives up premiums.
Your Hiring and HR Practices: A company with well-documented HR policies, an employee handbook, and a track record of fair practices will get a better rate than one that operates on a handshake and a prayer.
Your Claims History: If you’ve had a claim in the past, your premiums will likely be higher.
Now, here’s a little trick of the trade: you can often get a better deal by bundling your EPLI with your D&O policy.
Many insurers offer a package deal that combines the two, which can be more cost-effective than buying them separately.
Also, remember to consider your deductible.
This is the amount you have to pay out-of-pocket before the insurance kicks in.
A higher deductible will lower your premium, but you have to be prepared to pay that amount if a claim arises.
The key is to find the right balance for your startup’s financial situation.
I know, I know.
It’s another expense.
But think of it this way: EPLI is an investment in your company’s future.
It’s a small price to pay to avoid the potential bankruptcy and reputational damage that a single lawsuit could cause. —
Finding the Right EPLI Policy: A Step-by-Step Guide for Founders
Okay, you’re ready to get EPLI.
But how do you navigate the sometimes-confusing world of insurance to find the right policy for your startup?
Here’s a practical, no-nonsense guide to help you.
### Step 1: Understand Your Needs
Before you even talk to an insurance broker, you need to have a clear idea of what you need.
How many employees do you have?
What state(s) are they in?
What is your annual revenue?
Do you have an employee handbook?
Do you have a clear disciplinary process?
Having this information ready will make the process much smoother and will help you get a more accurate quote.
### Step 2: Find a Reputable Broker
Don’t try to go it alone.
An experienced insurance broker who specializes in working with startups can be your best friend.
They understand the unique risks you face and can help you find a policy that fits your budget and your needs.
Ask other founders in your network for recommendations.
A good broker will take the time to understand your business and will present you with options from multiple carriers.
### Step 3: Compare Policies and Carriers
Don’t just take the first quote you get.
Compare policies from different insurance carriers.
Look beyond the price.
Consider factors like:
Policy Limits: How much will the insurance pay out? For a startup, a $1 million limit is a good starting point.
Deductible: How much do you have to pay before the insurance kicks in?
Coverage: What specific claims are covered? Some policies are more comprehensive than others.
Legal Defense Costs: Are legal defense costs included within the policy limit, or are they covered in addition to it? This is a crucial detail to check.
Retroactive Date: Does the policy cover claims that arise from events that happened before the policy was in force? This is important if you’ve been operating for a while without coverage.
### Step 4: Read the Fine Print (or Have Your Broker Do It)
Insurance policies are notorious for their dense, confusing language.
Make sure you or your broker understands all the terms and conditions, especially the exclusions.
What *isn’t* covered by the policy is just as important as what is.
For instance, most EPLI policies do not cover wage and hour claims unless you specifically add an endorsement for it.
This is a critical point, as wage and hour claims are one of the most common types of employment lawsuits.
### Step 5: Implement Best Practices
Getting EPLI is just the first step.
The insurance carrier will want to see that you’re doing your part to mitigate risk.
This means having a solid employee handbook, clear and consistent HR policies, and a process for handling complaints.
This proactive approach can not only lower your premiums but also significantly reduce the likelihood of a lawsuit in the first place.
For a detailed guide on best practices for managing a growing team, you can check out this article from the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM).
—
Real-World Stories: How Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI) Saved Startups from Disaster
Sometimes, the best way to understand the importance of something isn’t by talking about theory, but by looking at real-life examples.
Let me share a couple of stories I’ve seen play out.
I’ve changed the names and details to protect the companies and individuals involved, but the core lessons are as real as it gets.
### Case Study 1: The Founder Who Didn’t Have a Paper Trail
A small tech startup in San Francisco had just raised a Series A round.
Things were great.
The founder, let’s call him Alex, was a brilliant engineer but had zero experience with HR.
He hired a new marketing director who, after a few months, simply wasn’t cutting it.
Their performance was poor, and they were a drain on the team’s morale.
Alex, being a direct person, had a conversation with the marketing director and let them go.
There was no formal performance improvement plan (PIP), no written warnings, just a verbal conversation and a termination.
The ex-employee immediately filed a **wrongful termination** lawsuit, claiming their firing was retaliation for raising concerns about a toxic work environment.
Alex was floored.
He had never even heard the term “toxic work environment” from this employee.
Luckily, Alex had a good insurance broker who had insisted he get EPLI from the very beginning.
The EPLI policy kicked in immediately.
The insurance company assigned a high-quality law firm to defend the case.
The legal battle lasted for months, and while Alex was able to focus on his company, the legal bills were astronomical—well over $75,000.
But because he had EPLI, he only had to pay his deductible.
The insurance carrier covered the rest.
Without that policy, that $75,000 would have come directly out of the startup’s bank account, likely forcing them to lay off other employees or even shut down.
### Case Study 2: The Innocent Conversation That Wasn’t
A small e-commerce startup had a diverse team of about 20 people.
One day, a team member, Sarah, mentioned to a manager that she was planning to go through a difficult medical procedure.
The manager, trying to be supportive, said something along the lines of, “Oh, I hope that doesn’t impact your ability to work on this big project.”
A few weeks later, Sarah was passed over for a promotion in favor of a newer employee.
Sarah immediately filed a lawsuit for **disability discrimination**, citing the manager’s comment as evidence that her medical condition was a factor in the decision.
The manager was mortified.
He insisted his comment was meant to be empathetic and that the promotion decision was based purely on performance.
But intent doesn’t matter in a courtroom; evidence does.
The legal defense for this case was incredibly complex, involving depositions, a review of performance records, and more.
The legal fees quickly mounted, but again, the startup’s EPLI policy was there to save the day.
It covered all the legal expenses and eventually led to a mediated settlement that was far less than the cost of a full trial.
The founder, in this case, later told me, “I thought my D&O policy would cover this. When my broker explained the difference and I saw the EPLI in action, I realized it was the most important insurance I had.”
These stories aren’t meant to scare you, but to illustrate a simple, undeniable truth: employment lawsuits happen to good people and good companies.
They’re often unexpected, and they can be financially devastating.
EPLI is the safety net that allows you to weather the storm and keep your company moving forward. —
Beyond Insurance: Best Practices to Mitigate Employment Practices Liability (EPLI) Risks
Getting EPLI is critical, but it’s not a silver bullet.
The best way to handle a lawsuit is to prevent it from happening in the first place.
Think of EPLI as the fire extinguisher, but these best practices are the smoke detectors and fire prevention plan.
You want both, right?
Here’s how you can build a more resilient company from the ground up:
### 1. Have a Comprehensive Employee Handbook
This is non-negotiable.
An employee handbook isn’t just a boring document; it’s a legal and cultural contract between you and your employees.
It should clearly outline your company’s policies on harassment, discrimination, termination, and disciplinary procedures.
Make sure every employee signs an acknowledgment that they have read and understood the handbook.
This can be a powerful piece of evidence if a claim ever arises.
### 2. Document Everything
When it comes to HR, the golden rule is: if it isn’t documented, it didn’t happen.
Document performance reviews, disciplinary actions, conversations about performance issues, and any complaints you receive.
This paper trail (or digital trail, more accurately) is your best friend in a legal battle.
It helps to demonstrate that your decisions were based on legitimate, non-discriminatory business reasons.
### 3. Train Your Managers
Your managers are your first line of defense against EPLI claims.
They need to be trained on what constitutes harassment and discrimination, how to handle employee complaints, and how to conduct performance reviews fairly and legally.
A single off-hand comment from an untrained manager can be enough to trigger a lawsuit.
### 4. Implement Clear and Consistent Policies
Fairness and consistency are key.
If you have a policy, you must apply it to all employees equally.
Don’t have a policy for one person and a different one for another.
Inconsistencies can be interpreted as a form of discrimination.
### 5. Consult an HR Professional or Employment Lawyer
As a founder, you can’t be an expert in everything.
Hiring an HR professional or retaining an employment lawyer on a consulting basis is a smart investment.
They can help you draft your employee handbook, review your policies, and guide you through difficult situations like terminations.
A few hours of a lawyer’s time upfront can save you years of legal headaches down the road.
This isn’t just about avoiding lawsuits; it’s about building a positive, healthy, and legally compliant company culture.
When your employees feel respected and heard, they’re less likely to feel the need to sue you.
And that’s a win-win for everyone.
For a wealth of resources on building a strong HR foundation for your startup, take a look at the Small Business Administration (SBA) website.
—
The Bottom Line: Your Startup’s Future Depends on EPLI
Running a startup is a thrilling, all-consuming adventure.
You’re a modern-day pioneer, charting a new course in an uncertain world.
But as you scale your company, you also need to build a fortress of protection around it.
I’ve seen too many founders get blindsided by an unexpected lawsuit that could have been avoided with a simple insurance policy.
Don’t let that be you.
**Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI)** isn’t an option.
It’s a necessity.
It’s the shield that protects your business from the very real and very terrifying risks that come with hiring, managing, and, unfortunately, terminating employees.
It’s a small investment that buys you invaluable peace of mind.
So, go get that insurance, write that employee handbook, and build the company you’ve always dreamed of—one that’s not just innovative, but also secure and resilient.
Your future self will thank you for it.
—
EPLI, startups, insurance, founder, risks